The 2008 Weblog Awards

Polls Are Open!

Vote Now!

With polls now open we need to describe one of the changes in the voting mechanism this year.

Every year review the vote logs and voting patterns from previous years to fortify our defenses against manual and automated poll spamming.  This year we've made changes to protect against a handful of savvy folks who take it upon themselves to try and ruin the fun for everyone else.

This year we've implemented additional defenses against poll spamming.  We can't go into all the changes, but we do want to alert you to one change that may affect a subset of users.

If there are multiple computers voting in a home, work, or corporate environment those voters should avoid voting at the same time or one right after another.  If you're not trying to cast votes in these situations simultaneously (or near simultaneously) then there shouldn't be any problem with them being counted.

Due to the sensitivity of this issue we can't really answer every question about our security measures, but know that we have multiple layers of security that are always balanced with providing open voting access to everyone.  The result is a secure, enjoyable experience.

Again, the vast majority of voters will never notice, nor be affected, by these changes, nor will the system ever drop a vote that they cast.  We just wanted to make sure everyone participating knows what's happening.

As we count down to the polls opening there's a few items of interest to pass on...

Polls will open on Jan. 5, but we don't have the exact time they'll open yet determined.  I know this may be an inconvenience to some, but we have to make sure everything is working before we get started.  All the polls are built, we're just running through our final tests to ensure the voting process is smooth.  If the polls don't open until the evening of the 5th we'll extend voting until Jan. 13 to give a full 7 days (and change) for voting.  We're shooting for an afternoon or morning kickoff for voting.

If you are a finalist and you haven't got you finalist badge, go here to get them.  We recommend changing the link to your poll page.

Embeddable polls (where you show the voting screen on your site) will roll out Tuesday or Wednesday.  We delay this to give traffic a chance to stabilize and so that we can phase the implementation of this feature.  Details on how to get the code and how to embed the poll on your page will be sent to the Weblog Awards New mailing list and published on each individual poll page.

To make sure our site is available for the crush tomorrow we have completely disabled comments to cut down server load they generate.  You can use Twitter, the forums, or e-mail is you need to reach us.

We'll see everyone tomorrow!

We know many of you have been waiting for this...

Finalist badges are now available here. 

To go with the logos, we've now published to poll locations for all categories here.

Finalist are encouraged to modify the link code provide on the logo page to link to their poll page instead of the main page.

Have a great weekend.  We'll have a couple more daily notes this weekend we hope everyone will read.

Don't forget voting begins Monday.

Every day we'll be updating the site with important information and observations about the progress of The 2008 Weblog Awards.

Today we're announcing that the permanent location of each of the 48 polls have been set.  The finalist polls can be reached via the main poll navigation page here.

All comments will be disabled later today.  Discussion is allowed on The Weblog Awards Forum.

Finalist badges will be available very soon - hopefully this evening.  We'll send that information to our e-mail list and update this post.

Update:  We were made aware of a finalist blog in the Best Sports Blog category that appears to be defunct.  Hugging Harold Reynolds was added from the standby list to the finalists slate.  No more changes are anticipated, nor will removal request be honored as the polls are being built now.  That is a labor intensive manual process that's very hard to reverse or modify.

By now most people have see the finalists. Following up on that listing there's a few issues I want to discuss.

Here is a complete list of the finalists for The 2008 Weblog Awards. Finalists badges (hosted by Imageshack) will be available Wednesday. Voting is scheduled to begin on January 5, 2009.

Please note that the names of the Technorati Autority categories have changed, and two of the categories were merged into one.  The master list of nominations posts is here.

I'd like to thank my team of volunteers who helped look through the thousands and thousands of nominations to come up with the best slate of finalists we've ever had.  For those who were nominated but not selected as finalist, please read this.

Every year this is the hardest post I have to write - the one where I explain why your nominated blog was not selected as a finalist.  First, the odds are heavily stacked against you.  This year we received over 5,000 nominations in 49 categories, of which no more than 500 will be selected as finalists.  That's only one in ten...

Second, it's worth restating the guiding principles of of The Weblog Awards; ones we've used since the inception of The Weblog Awards in 2003:

1) Open and public nominations
2) Categories that allow blogs of similar readership levels to compete
3) Real time vote totals
4) Quick turnaround of the results
5) Fun

An operation of this magnitude will never be without its share of controversy or problems. There's one part of The Weblog Awards that will never get any easier - the finalist cut down. Explaining why many nominated blogs are not finalists is always the trickiest part of The Weblog Awards.

To maximize participation there will be as little overlap in the selection of finalists in the categories as possible.  There are a couple notable exceptions to this edict [Note: It's a guideline, not an iron-clad rule], the Best Blog, Best Design, Best Political Coverage and Best Podcast categories.  Finalists in those categories may appear as finalists in other categories. Even with that general guideline there will be several thousands of nominated blogs that for one reason or another will not be finalists in any category.

Please understand that the constraints of the number of categories and the maximum number of finalists per category really ties our hands. The goal is to get the most representative slate of 10 finalists per category. We're under no illusion that (even with unlimited time) we could prune each category to a list of the 10 blogs that everyone would agree were the absolute best 10 blogs that category has to offer. We do what we can under incredible deadlines to pick the best slate possible. In the process we know that many excellent blogs were not selected...

This year we used the "me too" button to nomination comments.  The idea was to eliminate duplicate nominations.  As we said in advance this was just another piece of information for the judges to look at.  We knew that there may be sites that confused this with voting, but thought it was a valuable feature to add anyway.

If your blog was nominated, but is not selected as a finalist I want you to know how much I appreciate your participation in this years awards. With several thousand blogs nominated this kind of disappointment is an unfortunate consequence of the success of The Weblog Awards - one which will repeat every year. The prospect of anonymous and closed nomination, while it might lessen the disappointment of those not selected as finalists, is to my mind far less appealing than the open nomination process of The Weblog Awards.  Prolonging or expanding the voting likewise would detract from the festivites.

I wish it could be another way, but unfortunately it cannot...

Sunday (Dec. 28) Monday Dec. 29 we'll be announcing finalists in all categories.  The list is done now except for one category we're working furiously to finish.  Check back Monday night for the names of the 500+ sites selected as finalists.

Voting begins Jan. 5.  Stay tuned for details... 

Update:  Let me explain the delay.  What happened is we ended up with two Technorati category without enough nominees, so we've been working today to combine Best Large Blog and Best Mid Major Blog into one category.  The combined category will be called Best Large (Authority between 501 and 1000).  The remaining midsize category; Best Mid Minor Blog (Authority between 301 and 500) will be renamed Best Midsize Blog (Authority between 301 and 500).  All of the finalists are now selected, we're just doing a few more checks to make sure we've got it all correct before publishing the 500+ finalists later this evening.

Thanks to a record number of nominations, nearly 5,000, the finalist selection process is going much slower than it has in previous years.  Right now we're on track to finish within the next week, however that really pushes the voting closer to Christmas than we would like.

In previous years we've not had time to fully populate things like RSS/Atom feed links for all 500 finalist blogs and we've generally not had enough time after completing the finalist slate to do things we'd like (such as notifying finalist sites, scheduling press releases, and poll testing) before voting overtakes us. 

This year will be different.  We'll announce finalists a full week before voting and have all of our finalist feed links populated when voting opens.  One of the major goals of The Weblog Awards is to expose the world to a wide variety of blogs and to increase readership of all finalist blogs.  By giving ourself a little extra time we can better publicize the finalist slates and make sure that more people are aware of the voting period and the selected finalists blogs.

Last year we introduced embeddable polls in selected categories a few days into the competition.  This allowed sites to include Weblog Award voting polls on their own pages.  For us this was a fairly revolutionary step.  This year we plan to offer embeddable polls in all categories from day one.  Since we've not conducted a full scale test of the poll embedding, on December 30 we will make available a special test poll "Best Blogging System" that we will ask other sites to embed on their websites for a few days.  This should be a fun experiment for any site that wants to offer a real-time poll to it's readers and will help us ensure that the system is ready for the deluge of traffic that embedding polls will generate.

As you can see there's lots of work involved in making The Weblog Awards the biggest and best blog competition in the world.  We're committed, just as we have always been, to making our competition as open, fun, and inviting as possible.  Sweating the details is a big part of past success.  This year we're giving ourself an extra week or two to make sure every detail is sweated, making things as rock solid as possible. 

Here is the final schedule for The 2008 Weblog Awards:

Finalist Announced - December 28

Finalist Voting Page Available* - December 31

Finalist Voting - January 5 through January 12

We know that the delay is frustrating, it's frustrating for us as well, but we also know that we've set a high standard for excellence in the past; a standard we strive to exceed every year.  The new schedule allows us to make The 2008 Weblog Awards bigger, better, and more excellent than ever before.

* The voting page for all polls will open several days before the poll becomes active.  This allows us time to publicize the voting page link (which will be the link that readers use to get to the voting screen) prior to the beginning of voting.  This will help finalist blogs setup sidebar links directly to their poll.  It will also allow us to pre-publicize the embeddable poll code.

Thanks to everyone who nominated blogs this year!  We had a record number of nominations - over 4,800 at last count.

We've closed nominations in nearly all of the 49 categories, but we've left a few open while we work on producing finalist slates for all of the categories. 

Here are the categories still accepting nominations:

Best Large Blog (Technorati Authority over 1001)
Best Mid Major Blog (Technorati Authority between 751 and 1000)
Best Mid Minor Blog  (Technorati Authority between 501 and 750)
Best Small Major Blog  (Technorati Authority between 301 and 500)

Nominations will close in those categories soon, so don't delay in nominating sites.  Also if our readers could spread the word to some bloggers in those categories.

We have been hard at work sifting through the nominees and building finalist slates.  We'll be posting here about the progress all week, this weekend, and next week.  Right now we're scheduled to start voting on December 8, 2008 and nothing,so far, has got us off course for that start date.

Keep visiting the site to get details on the finalist selection process, examples of the voting polls, news about embeddable polls this year, finalist announcements, finalist badges, and much more.

Thanks!

Nominations for The 2008 Weblog Awards have begun.  Click here to see the master list of categories where you can nominate your favorite blogs.  You can also get site badges, and learn how you can get involved in this year's festivities.

It's going to be bigger and better than ever, start spreading the word...

Links to all of the nominations posts are available via this link.